Crafting the perfect old fashioned cocktail requires the right whiskey, and for many enthusiasts, bourbon remains the classic choice. Bourbon’s balanced, smooth, and sweet profile creates a mellow and accessible final sip, making it an ideal spirit for this beloved cocktail.
Key Takeaways:
- Bourbon offers a smooth, sweet flavour that’s perfect for old fashioned cocktails
- Rye whiskey provides a spicy, peppery character as an alternative base
- Non-whiskey spirits like brandy, tequila, and rum can also make tasty old fashioned variations
Bourbon: The Classic Choice for Old Fashioned
When it comes to crafting an old fashioned, bourbon is the quintessential choice. The spirit’s balanced flavour profile, with notes of caramel, vanilla, and oak, creates a smooth, approachable sip that’s perfect for this iconic cocktail. Compared to the spicier, more assertive rye, bourbon’s sweeter and richer character makes it an excellent option for those seeking a classic, easy-drinking old fashioned.
Top Bourbon Picks for Old Fashioned
When it comes to bourbon for your old fashioned, a few standout options rise to the top. Woodford Reserve Double Oaked offers an ultra-smooth, rich, and buttery flavour that creates a luxurious old fashioned. For those seeking a budget-friendly option, Evan Williams Bottled in Bond is known as “the king of the budget old fashioned” with its sturdy proof, modest age, and punchy flavour. And for a more mature, characterful old fashioned, Knob Creek delivers significantly more complexity than some of the more budget-friendly options.
Other top bourbon choices for old fashioned include Buffalo Trace, Bulleit, and Eagle Rare 10 Year Old.
Rye Whiskey: An Intriguing Alternative
While bourbon is the classic, rye whiskey offers an entirely different flavour profile that can make for a captivating old fashioned. Rye brings more spice, peppery tones, and herbal notes compared to bourbon’s sweeter, richer character. This leaner, more assertive profile delivers the “rye spice” side of the equation with greater drinkability and flourishes of citrus and vanilla.
Some of the top rye whiskey options for old fashioned include Michter’s Straight Rye, High West Double Rye, Rittenhouse Rye, Bulleit Rye, and Wild Turkey Rare Breed.
Brandy, Tequila, and Beyond: Non-Whiskey Variations
While whiskey may be the traditional base, the old fashioned can be successfully made with a wide range of spirits, each bringing its own distinct flavour profile. From a Wisconsin Old Fashioned made with brandy to a Tequila Old Fashioned or even a Mezcal Old Fashioned, the possibilities for spirit variations are endless. Other non-whiskey options include the Oaxaca Old Fashioned, Rum Old Fashioned, Gin Old Fashioned, and a Maple Old Fashioned.
Customising the Old Fashioned
At its core, the old fashioned remains a delightfully simple cocktail, consisting of just three essential ingredients: whiskey (or spirit base), sugar (or flavoured syrup), and bitters. However, the customisation options are where the old fashioned truly shines. Experimenting with different bitters varieties, including Angostura, orange, mole/chocolate, and cherry/spiced, can dramatically alter the flavour profile. And using alternative sweeteners like semi-rich simple syrup, real maple syrup, and agave nectar can also put a unique spin on the classic.
The Importance of Whiskey Selection
When it comes to the old fashioned, the choice of whiskey dramatically affects the final flavour profile, mouthfeel, and overall drinking experience. Budget-friendly options like Evan Williams can deliver punchy flavour but risk becoming weak or diluted. Mid-range selections like Knob Creek, on the other hand, can match restaurant-quality standards. And premium whiskeys bring more sophisticated, nuanced profiles. Additionally, higher proof whiskeys like Evan Williams White Label (100 proof) stand up better to large ice cubes without becoming overly diluted.
Smoky and Peaty Alternatives
For those seeking a distinctly different old fashioned experience, the Talisker Old Fashioned offers a unique twist. Using Talisker Skye Single Malt, this cocktail delivers a smoky, peaty profile that creates an entirely different flavour profile compared to the classic bourbon or rye old fashioned.
In conclusion, the old fashioned is a timeless cocktail that allows for a wide range of spirit choices and customisation options. Whether you prefer the smooth, balanced profile of bourbon, the spicy, peppery notes of rye, or even non-whiskey alternatives, there’s an old fashioned variation to suit every discerning palate. With a bit of experimentation and exploration, you’ll be well on your way to crafting the perfect old fashioned at home.
Sources:
“Best Whiskey for an Old Fashioned” – Cooking with Janica
“The ULTIMATE Old Fashioned list | 8 Classic & Modern Variations” – House of Bitter Bear (YouTube)
“Cocktail Queries: What Are Best Whiskeys for an Old Fashioned? Bourbon and Rye Cocktails Overproof” – Paste Magazine
“Best Old Fashioned Recipes: 10 Delicious Twists on a Classic Cocktail” – This Gal Cooks
“Old Fashioned recipe variations” – Difford’s Guide
“The Best Whisky for an Old Fashioned | Bourbon and Beyond” – Malts
“Top 3 Whiskies for an Old Fashioned (Best Value Bourbon Picks)” – YouTube Shorts
